Study examines the way pre-school children identify colours
Children developing colour concepts have ‘blindness to background’ as they struggle to identify colour existing independently of objects, new research has revealed.
Experts at Aberystwyth University and Newcastle University have looked at the way pre-school children identify colours.
A research study conducted by Dr Catherine O’Hanlon, Lecturer in Developmental and Neurodevelopmental Psychology at Aberystwyth University, is shortly to be published in the scientific journal Developmental Science.
Despite colour being an important aspect of human visual experience, it often takes toddlers many months of teaching and reinforcing before they learn to apply colour words correctly and consistently.
“When it comes to colour, two to four year old children really struggle” explains Dr O’Hanlon from the University’s Department of Psychology. “The words are learned relatively late and the concepts developed even later.”
Professor Jenny Read, Professor of Vision Science at the Institute of Neuroscience at Newcastle University, who was co-investigator on the project, explains the background to the research: “The idea for the study came from one time when I was looking at a book with my two year old son. I asked him “Can you see something red?” and he pointed to a red object. I asked him “Can you see something green?” and he pointed to a green object. I then asked him “Can you see something blue?” However, he couldn’t find anything blue. That was really surprising because what we were looking at was actually a seascape; almost the entire page was blue!”
Dr O’Hanlon explains: “Our study took a novel approach to investigate whether toddlers only think about colour as being ‘part of an object’, and struggle to conceptualise colour as existing independently of objects.”
The research study involved showing children aged between two and twelve years a selection of simplistic pictures on a touch screen monitor, and asking them to point to a particular colour. In each case that colour was either a foreground object, the background of the image, or was absent altogether. Eye movement patterns were recorded as participants scanned the image.
The researchers found that young children were fast and accurate at pointing to foreground objects of that particular colour, but when the colour was the image’s background, younger children indicated that the colour was not present.
The study identified an inbuilt tendency to focus on objects and, what the researchers have termed, a ‘blindness to background’. This is a striking phenomenon which has not previously been reported, and the researchers believe that this natural bias may slow the acquisition of colour words and the development of colour concepts in toddlers.
Interestingly, the research found that although the young children focused on foreground objects when the linguistic cue was a colour adjective, the blindness to background effect disappeared with the use of nouns. So, for example, if the child was shown a picture of an aquarium and asked to point to ‘water’ instead of ‘blue’, they quickly shifted their attention to the background and pointed at it.
Dr Catherine O’Hanlon added: “What was really interesting was that when the colour that we asked the child to find was the background of the image, the child made a real effort to locate the colour on the picture. In fact, before indicating that the colour was not there, they searched for the same amount of time as they searched when the colour was actually absent from the picture. Basically, if the colour was the background of the picture, despite really looking, they simply couldn’t ‘see’ it.”
The research found that sometime between the age of four and five years old, the blindness to background effect is overcome.
Photo: Dr Catherine O’Hanlon, Department of Psychology, Aberystwyth University
Full article: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/desc.12478/abstract
Developmental Science Video Abstract: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TKO1BPeAiOI
Department of Pyschology: https://www.aber.ac.uk/en/psychology/